Insights

7 Ways to Make Retargeting Strategies More Effective

Someone visits your website. They browse a product, read a service page, or even make it all the way to checkout. Then… they vanish. Sound familiar?

However, when your site gets ghosted, as it were, it doesn’t necessarily mean those visitors are gone forever. In fact, that disappearing act can actually be a good thing, and the beginning of a new advertising opportunity with retargeting strategies.

Retargeting is basically reconnecting with your website visitors through ads. But the most effective retargeting isn’t just about putting a pixel on your site and following visitors around the internet. The best retargeting campaign strategies are more specific than that, and they use things like audience behavior, funnel stage, timing, creative, and customer data to make the ads more relevant.

Here are seven retargeting best practices to help you get more from your digital advertising budget, according to Benjamin Rorie, VP Paid Media Manager at The Threadgill Agency.

 

1. Start With Smarter Audience Segmentation

For Rorie, one of the biggest mistakes in digital advertising retargeting is treating every website visitor as the same consumer, when, of course, they’re not.

For example, someone who landed on your homepage for 10 seconds isn’t necessarily as valuable as someone who spent five minutes comparing your products. Someone who abandoned a shopping cart has demonstrated a very different level of intent than someone who read a blog post.

A few of the most useful ways to segment include:

  • Lifetime value: Someone who bought a higher-priced product may be a good candidate for related higher-value products or services. They shouldn’t necessarily get the same ads as someone who made a smaller purchase.
  • Buyer vs. non-buyer: Someone who just bought a product shouldn’t continue seeing acquisition-focused ads. Give them some time before coming back with a cross-sell or upsell message.​
  • Funnel phase: Someone who just casually visited a page is likely in a much different mindset than someone who viewed a product, added it to cart, or made it all the way to checkout. Because their level of interest differs, the ad messages they see should change.

 

2. Match Ads to What People Actually Viewed

If someone looked at a particular product, there’s probably not a huge need to show them a generic ad for your entire company. That’s where product-based retargeting comes in. Whenever possible, show the exact product someone viewed but didn’t purchase. “For e-commerce brands, dynamic retargeting can automate this process by serving ads featuring the products individual users previously viewed,” said Rorie.

You can also make that follow-up ad more compelling by adding an incentive, like a limited-time discount, a bundle, free shipping, or an upgrade or bonus.

For service-based businesses, it’s the same. Page-based retargeting can promote the specific service featured on the page someone visited.

 

3. Build Your Strategy Around the Funnel Stage

Not every visitor is ready to buy or answer your call to action, and your ads shouldn’t pretend they are. Someone who is just learning about a service may need more information. Someone who has compared options may need proof. A cart abandoner may simply need a nudge to finish the purchase.

That’s why retargeting by funnel stage is another incredibly useful campaign strategy.

​This approach also opens the door to sequential messaging. Instead of showing someone the same creative for three weeks, change the message as their relationship with your brand develops.

 

4. Don’t Be a Digital Stalker

Retargeting works because it keeps your brand in front of people who have already demonstrated interest. It stops working when people see your ad every single time they open Instagram.

“This is where frequency capping comes in,” said Rorie. “Uncapped retargeting can quickly burn through your budget while irritating prospective customers and accelerating creative fatigue.”

​You can set frequency caps based on platform, campaign, and the length of your buying cycle.

​Timing is another important piece of the puzzle, because a site visitor from yesterday generally has stronger intent than someone who visited 60 days ago. So your retargeting strategies should reflect that rather than treating every visitor as equally valuable.

​In that same vein, a customer who just bought something usually doesn’t need to see another acquisition ad within five minutes. Build in a cool-off period before launching post-purchase cross-sell or upsell campaigns.

 

5. Go Beyond Pixel-Based Retargeting

“Digital advertising is changing rapidly, and advertisers can no longer rely exclusively on browser-based tracking,” said Rorie.

That makes first-party data retargeting increasingly important.

​Customer relationship management (CRM) data can be matched to ad platforms to create audiences based on known customer relationships.

This is one reason your website, analytics, and CRM shouldn’t operate as separate pieces of your marketing stack. The more intentionally those systems work together, the more useful your customer data becomes.

 

6. Use High-Intent Audiences to Find Lookalikes

Retargeting strategies don’t only apply to people who have already visited your site. Lookalike audiences can build on what you know about high-intent visitors to help you reach new people with similar characteristics.

​But there’s an important distinction.

“Don’t automatically build lookalikes from everyone who visited your site,” Rorie said.

Start with stronger signals. For example, you might build lookalikes from:

  • Product or service page viewers
  • Checkout completers
  • High-value customers
  • Other high-intent conversion audiences

 

7. Connect Your Retargeting Across Channels

“Most consumers aren’t going to experience your marketing messages through just one channel,” said Rorie.

Someone might discover your business on Google. Then, they might see your brand on Instagram. Eventually, they could convert by searching on their iPhone or tablet.

​Your retargeting strategy should account for that journey. That means thinking about cross-device and cross-channel consistency.

​Someone who viewed a product on mobile shouldn’t encounter completely disconnected messaging when they later see your desktop brand. Campaigns should work together rather than telling completely different stories.

​The goal isn’t to bombard people everywhere. It’s to create a consistent experience wherever they encounter your brand.

 

P.S. Don’t Forget Suppression Lists

There’s one final piece of retargeting that deserves attention: who you don’t want to target. Suppression lists can actually be just as important as inclusion lists.

​Your campaigns should actively exclude audiences like recent buyers and people who have already completed an intended action, along with employees and other audiences that don’t make sense.

Removing these lists prevents wasted impressions and helps your advertising dollars go further.

 

Retargeting Strategies Must Start with Your Site

With retargeting strategies, the goal isn’t to show more ads to more people. It’s to show the right message to the right person at the right moment. But it’s also incredibly important to give them a website experience that makes the next step easy.

​That’s why website development has to be about more than just aesthetics, said Rorie.

At Threadgill, we work closely with our clients to ensure they have a strategic site with clear paths to the information, products, and services their consumers are looking for. Site pages should support the different stages of the customer journey, while analytics and tracking should capture meaningful actions so retargeting campaigns have useful signals to work with.

​If you’re interested in learning more about how we can help your business’s digital marketing efforts, from retargeting strategies to paid media, website development, and beyond, let’s talk.